...
In the hierarchy of Sudanese laws, constitutional law prevails over any act of the legislature: This applies to bills of the national legislature (See Article 83 of the Interim National Constitution of the Republic of Suda) but is likewise valid for legal acts of the executive where it is vested with delegated powers to enact regulations (See Article 115 of the Interim National Constitution of the Republic of Sudan). In view of the trias politica, the Interim National Constitution formally governs the executive authority and the judiciary: It prevails over any act of the executive, and it also ranks above the Interim Constitution of Southern Sudan and the states constitutions (dasātīr al-wilāyāt). In order to harmonize laws with international standards as provided for in the Interim National Constitution, the lajna al-murāja'a al-_qānūnīa __(Law Review Committee), established by the Sudanese Government within the National Ministry of Justice, brings domestic legislation in line with the provisions of the Interim National Constitution (Elliesie 2009: 64). These laws include, _inter alia_, the qānūn al-ijrā'āt al-jinā'īa (Criminal Procedure Act of 1991); the qānūn al-quwwāt al-musallaha (People's Armed Forces Act of 1986); the qānūn quwwāt ash-shurta as-sūdānīa (Police Forces Act of 1999); and the qānūn al-qadā' (Judiciary Act of 1986) (Opening Remarks delivered by the Sudanese Minister of Justice at a Law Reform Workshop on September 2006 in Khartoum organized by the United Nations Mission in Sudan). In doing so, it remains to be seen whether the Ministry of Justice addresses the issue of the crucial and controversial status of the office of the Chief Public Prosecutor (an-nā'ib al-'āmm), which was set up according to Article 197 of the National Constitution of 1973. By virtue of his office, the an-nā'ib al-'āmm should be an independent organ of the judiciary. Due to the constitutional separation of powers, the office should neither be constrained by directives of the executive branch of the state, nor should it be mixed with their authority. In Sudan, however, this is not the case: The an-nā'ib al-'āmm is, by virtue of his office, Minister of Justice (ad-Dīn 2006: 37).
...
The war situation in the Sudan has, however, promoted the exercise of unchecked power, of the executive authority by security services and in the political manipulation of the court system. Since 2005, all national laws and legal acts must, on the other hand, comply with the Interim National Constitution of the Sudan. To cope with this prospect, the process of law reform is quite challenging: Not only does Sudanese law lack a provision allowing for prosecution on the basis of command responsibility, Sudan has enacted many immunity provisions that impede the prosecution of those in the military, police, and security agencies who are responsible for crimes particular with regard to Darfur (Elliesie 2010, Elliesie 2007: 199 et seqq.). Immunity for members of national security forces was enshrined in the qānūn al-amn al-_wataniyy __(National Security Forces Act_
qānūn quwwāt ash-shurta as-sūdāniyya (Police Forces Act of 1999) stipulates that "no criminal procedure will be taken against any police officer for a crime committed while executing his official duty or as a consequence of those official duties without permission of the Minister of the Interior". Furthermore, Criminal Decree No. 3/95 sets forth requirements for bringing charges against members of the armed forces in criminal courts and specifies that criminal courts have no authority to pursue charges without approval by the armed forces or a decree from the Chief Justice. In addition, a temporary decree issued by the President on 4 August 2005, attempted to extend immunity of the armed forces by amending the _qānūn al-quwwāt al-musallaha Wiki-Markup {_}of 1999). Article 33 of that act states, that "no civil or criminal proceedings shall be instituted against a member, or collaborator, for any act connected with the official work of the member, save upon approval of the Director \[...\]". Similar language can be found in other acts and decrees regulating government actors as well. Article 46 of the{_}
Jannjāwīd in protection from prosecution without government consent (Elliesie 2009: 59).Wiki-Markup (People's Armed Forces Act) stating that "there shall not be taken any procedure against any officer, ranker \[sic\!\] or soldier who committed an act that may constitute a crime done during or for the reason of the execution of his duties or any lawful order made to him in this capacity and he shall not be tried except by the permission of the General Commander or whoever authorized by him." This decree extended protection for the armed forces by including the PDF-militia and
...
| Panel | ||
|---|---|---|
BibliographyAd-Dīn, Jamāl (2006): Alī at-Tūm, tashrī' as-sūdānī fī mīzān huqūq al-insān (silsila dirāsāt huqūq al-'insān, no. 12), Markaz al-Qāhira li-Dirāsāt Huqūq al-'Insān, Cairo, p. 37 Attia Musa, Ismail / Ibrahim Hussein, Farida / Wuol Makec, John (1997): _ The Role of the Judiciary in the Protection of Human Rights in the Sudan, Eugene Cotran / Adel Omar Sherif: The Role of the Judiciary in the Protection of Human Rights, CIMEL Book Series No. 5, London et al., pp. 126-... Basha, Sara (2006): The Comprehensive Peace Agreement - A Synopsis, Brian Raftopoulos / Karin Alexander (eds.): Peace in Balance: The Crisis in Sudan, Institute for Justice and Reconciliation, Cape Town, pp. 23-... Dann, Philipp / Al-Ali, Zaid (2006): The Internationalized Pouvoir Constituant - Constitution Making under external Influence in Iraq, Sudan and East Timor, Max Planck Yearbook of United Nations Law, Volume 10, Leiden et al., 2006, pp. 423-... Elliesie, Hatem (20052005a)a: Friedensprozess und Verfassungsentwicklung im Sudan, Verfassung und Recht in Übersee (Law and Politics in Africa, Asia and Latin America), Volume 8/3, Baden-Baden et al., p. 276-... Elliesie, Hatem (20052005b)b: Quo vadis bilād as-Sūdān? The Contemporary Framework for a National Interim Constitution, Recht in Afrika, Volume 8/1, Köln, pp. 63-... Elliesie, Hatem (2007): Die Darfur-Krise im Sudan und das Völkerrecht: Eine Herausforderung für die Vereinten Nationen (UN) und den Internationalen Strafgerichtshofes (ICC), Verfassung und Recht in Übersee 40, Volume 40/2, Baden-Baden et al., pp. 199-229 Elliesie, Hatem / et al. (2009): Different Approaches to Genocide-Trials under National Jurisdiction on the African Continent - The Rwandan, Sudanese and Ethiopian Case, Recht in Afrika, Volume 12/1, Köln, pp. 21-...
Fadlalla, Mohamed (2009): The Regulation and Meaning of Concurrent Powers in the Interim National Constitution 2005 of Suda, Recht in Afrika, Volume 12/1, Köln, pp. 131-... Gouraud, Sebastien (2006): Rule of Law in Sudan's three Area, Forced Migration, Issue 26, Refugee Studies Center, Oxford, p. 58 Ibrahim, Noha (2008): The Right to a Fair Trail in the Light of the Interim National Constitution: Theory and Practice, Recht in Afrika, Volume 11/1, Köln, pp. 83-... Juba Declaration on Dialogue and National Consensus, Chapter 4 (Democratic Transformation), para. ii et seq Khalid, Mansour / Biong Deng, Luka (2007): The Sudan Comprehensive Agreement, Peter Gwynvay Hopkins (ed.): The Kenana Handbook of Sudan, London et al., pp. 811-... Machakos Protocol, Part B (The Transition Process), 2 Morrision, Fred L. (2007): The World's Most Complex Constitution: The Interim Constitutional Framework of the Sudan, August Reinisch / Ursula Kriebaum (eds.): The Law of International Relations - Liber Amicorum Hans Peter Neuhold, Utrecht, pp. 229-... Omer Medani, Fareed (2007): The Salient Features of the Sudan Interim National Constitutional Constitution, Peter Gwynvay Hopkins (ed.): The Kenana Handbook of Sudan, London et al., pp. 803-... Redress Trust (2009): Promoting Law Reform in Sudan to enhance Human Rights Protection, Strengthen the Rule of Law and foster Democratic Process, Written Evidence submitted by the Redress Trust to the UK Associate Parliamentary Group on Sudan: Parliamentary Hearings: Sudan's Comprehensive Peace Agreement, London, pp. 3-... United Nations (2009): Report of the Secretary-General on Elections in the Sudan, New York, UN-Doc. S/2009/391, para. 31-34 |
